Health Commissioner Defends Closing Children's Dental Clinics, Funding Anti-Smoking Ads
By Azi PaybarahIn continuing testimony at the City Council's budget hearing on H.H.S., Health Commissioner Thomas Frieden is defending his agency’s decision to save money by closing dental clinics for children, but not, for example, reducing funds for the anti-smoking campaign, which he said costs $5 million annually.
“Compared with all of the other options, we see this as the least bad,” said Commissioner Frieden, referring to the clinics.
Frieden told City Council members that funding “dramatic” anti-smoking campaigns correlates with a decline in the number of New Yorkers who smoke. Frieden said making cuts to that advertising campaign would result in “more deaths.”
Later, when asked by City Councilman Oliver Koppell, the commissioner admitted that the money the city receives from the state and federal government from an omnibus anti-smoking settlement is “not earmarked for any specific purpose.”
Koppell then said, “That money is used for budget balancing,” and wondered aloud, if, during a budget crisis, not smoking should return to being the “responsibility of the individual.”
Frieden maintained throughout the exchange that if the advertising campaign was reduced, “more people would die.”
Contributors
Steve Kornacki
As Hail Mary passes go, this one isn’t bad.
Since his popularity collapsed back in January, David Paterson has been in a nearly impossible ... >
Jason Horowitz
As the New York political universe waits to see what Attorney General Andrew Cuomo says about the legality of David Paterson's selection of ... >
Joe Conason
The new senator from Minnesota is a comedian, writer and actor who lived on the Upper West Side of Manhattan and raised a lot of money from friends ... >
Eliot Brown
Richard Ravitch has been a groundhog of New York politics over the past few decades. He pops up at unpredictable moments into full public view, ... >
RSS Feeds
Send tips to: azi.paybarah@politickerny.com or jimmy.vielkind@politickerny.com
AIM:
azipaybarah or jimmyvielkind
Top Tags
Most Active Stories
- The Malaise-Proofing of Michael Bloomberg
- Liz Krueger on the Maloney Seat: It Beats Working in Albany
- In Picking LG, Paterson Picks a Fight With Cuomo
- Two Proposals, Claims of Progress
- Democrats Amigos Walk Out of Democratic Session as Espada Hints at Another Dramatic 'Solution'
- Paterson's Hail Mary
- Once Again, Amid the Chaos, Ravitch
- Garodnick, Too, Would Consider Maloney's Seat 'At the Appropriate Time'
- Dems Still Split on Operating Agreement
- Cy Vance: 'My Savior'
- Malcolm Smith Has a New M.T.A. Plan; 'We Did Not Take a Count,' Says Spokesman
- Obama Sells Out a Friend From Connecticut
- Citywide Candidates Celebrate Year of the Ox
- Patrick Gaspard Writes Poems, Collects Comics, Kills for Obama
- Obama Redefines the Debate for New York's Israel Boosters
- Kirsten Gillibrand, Like Chuck Schumer With Connections
- The Many Rabbis of Sonia Sotomayor
- Michael Bloomberg and the Universal Retainer
- Be Like Cuomo: Call AIG's Bluff
- A Labor Ad for Ferreras
Quote of the Day
Syndicate
Lord Bloomberg, Saviour of Millions;
I think it's pretty arrogant to say, "my anti-smoking campaign causes hordes of people not to smoke." I think the price has discouraged a few, I think the ad campaigns helps a few more, and maybe nudges a few to quit, or not start. But I think we already pay fortunes to teach our children the truth about smoking, at young an important ages. I'm VERY suspicious that these ad campaigns really do all that much, especially to the adults they are aimed at.
Hasn't anyone noticed that the entire world….even freakin France has begun to see the light on tobacco use? The whole world is waking up to this reality on their own, as our society advances in knowledge and sophistication. I don't think that our dear and awesome mayor, even though it's one of his biggest personal pet peeves, can take credit for something that has been going on in places like San Francisco and L.A. a full decade ahead of us.
I can forgive his ego's need to feel ownership of this victory….way to go Mr. Mayor, here' s your soccer trophy. But to use it as justification to cut needy children's dental care? I still can't believe I'm reading this correctly. Please someone close to him, give him a little glove-slap, please?
Post new comment